Justin Baldoni has acknowledged under oath that he told a pregnant Blake Lively he is circumcised during a private conversation at her New York apartment, and that remark has now become one of the most explosive details in their ongoing harassment and smear-campaign court battle. The disclosure is fueling fresh debate over boundaries, power, and what counts as inappropriate sexual conduct in Hollywood.
What Baldoni Admitted
According to newly filed court documents, Baldoni confirmed in an October 2025 deposition that he told Lively he is circumcised while visiting her New York City home in December 2022, when she was pregnant with her youngest son. He said the topic came up during a discussion about whether her unborn baby would be circumcised and admitted he volunteered the information even though Lively did not “directly” ask about his own body.
Baldoni’s testimony describes the exchange as happening in a busy room, with Lively’s husband Ryan Reynolds, nannies, assistants, and household staff moving in and out as they talked. When pressed on whether he normally discusses his genitalia with co-workers, Baldoni insisted he does not talk about his private parts with colleagues.
Lively’s Harassment Allegations
Lively’s amended complaint says she was “disturbed” that Baldoni described his own genitalia to her, and she cites the circumcision conversation as one of multiple incidents where she says he crossed clear professional lines. She alleges that on and off the set of It Ends With Us, the director and co-star made her uncomfortable with sexualized comments and conduct that she characterizes as harassment rather than friendly banter.
Beyond the circumcision remark, Lively accuses Baldoni and his allies of helping orchestrate a behind-the-scenes smear campaign designed to paint her as the problem after she spoke up about his behavior. Her lawsuit claims that reputational assault cost her tens of millions of dollars and “hijacked” her career as the movie’s release turned into a high-stakes PR war.
Baldoni’s Defense and Counters
Baldoni has denied wrongdoing and portrays the circumcision chat as part of a broader, once-mutual comfort between colleagues that Lively later reframed as harassment. In separate legal filings of his own, he has claimed that Lively was so at ease around him that she breast-fed in front of him during work meetings and that any intimacy-related requests on set, such as for an intimacy coordinator, were honored.
His team argues that Lively is following what he calls a “Taylor Swift playbook” by casting herself as a victim in the press and in court while misrepresenting private interactions that he says were consensual and professional at the time. Baldoni’s lawyers have asked the judge to throw out Lively’s lawsuit through summary judgment, saying the evidence does not support a harassment or smear-campaign claim.
Where the Legal Battle Stands
The case now hinges in part on how a judge and potentially a jury interpret the circumcision conversation and other disputed moments between the stars. Lively’s team is urging the court to send the matter to a full trial, arguing that Baldoni’s own deposition admissions show a pattern of boundary-crossing behavior that should be evaluated by jurors.
Baldoni’s lawyers, meanwhile, are pushing for the lawsuit to be dismissed before trial, insisting that awkward or overly personal comments do not meet the legal threshold for harassment or a coordinated smear campaign. A federal judge is expected to decide in the coming months whether the case proceeds to a March 2026 trial, meaning Baldoni’s off-hand remark about being circumcised could end up as a central piece of evidence in one of Hollywood’s most closely watched legal showdowns.
Hello friends, my name is Jai Patel, I am a content writer. I write tech related content in this website Filmy office.
I have more than 3 years of experience in writing blogs and I hope that you will like the information in our blog.
Stay connected to our site for latest Updates.
